Monday, April 22, 2013

The National Counter Terrorism Authority (NCTA)


I get the need for comfort, to relieve terror and return to normalcy and heal.  How a community so traumatized as Boston now seeks normalcy.  The swiftest relief is found by immediate myth making and covering over  your failures and seeing your  weakness and shame as attributes, as  a sign of strength and courage - "Boston Strong".   To not do so is almost unbearable.

That is understandable, but the  Boston community relief celebration and posturing  cannot conflate to policy review or corrupt the vital honest debriefing of the event, of all the players,  both terrorists and public authorities alike.  For to conflate or corrupt  policy formulation and response by basing it on myth  and fear is, of course, the basic goal of terrorism in the first place.

We must get Boston "right".

Right now Boston, at least  the surface of the  post-event consideration  in the public eye, is making this terrible error, replacing reality and building myth, infusing fantasy when the most vital clear and real understanding of the event is required.  This makes the Tsarnaevs' victory even more profound, more destructive.

NYC  9/11 could not go through this process of fantasy making and myth building  as the  sheer scope and terror  of the event could  only result in reality.  It is impossible to see the heroic in no other light for what it was, heroic - or the futile and abject terror for what exactly what  it was.  The policy failure was undeniable.  Therefore the NYC  response then had the ability to build immediately on a sheet of paper cleansed by harsh reality, basically unburdened by terrible cathartic results of past error.  Giuliani, backed by a man of steel Commissioner Kerik (who's actions during 9/11 made his later fraud inexplicable), responded with near text book perfection immediately, and then built and repaired the NYC weakness that perhaps contributed to the attack.  The CIA was calling on NYPD looking for intelligence and translations and cultural briefings on the enemy - and NYC counter terrorism techniques became the example for the nation.  But always it was the incredible sheer size of the event and the obviousness of the problem that allowed this completely new beginning.  It seems to be working.

But Boston is not the same story.  Boston clearly learned little or nothing from NYC in terms of counterterrorism for crowd events prior to the event, and seems to be learning nothing from the event itself. 
When one approaches a parade in NYC now,  tables are set up blocks away at most access points to check back packs and bulk items.  Non-participants are kept away from key areas of start or finish lines unless their presence is explained. The office of OEM is in daily contact with the CIA and FBI - and the dialogue is a valuable two way traffic in policing.  Arial surveillance, random impact patrols and all environment sporadic checks are always in force. Manuals are written and policy closely coordinated between state, transit, and NYPD.  State police seem to have fully trained counterterrorism force that works easily with NYPD, MTA, and PA. NYPD does not wait on the FBI to tell them who the potential bad guys are but conducts their own intelligence operations.  NYPD is accountable and to date, successful.

As the Boston event  unfolded,  none of the NYC  lessons learned seemed to be in place.   Instead of the constant and sole presence of the Mayor and Kerik during 9/11, 101 political actors took the stage in Boston,  and then it was pretty clear that political calculus was often  involved.  Policy was haphazard and created on the spot.  What does one do when terrorist are cornered in a residential area?   Why encounter them with force and empty all your clips!  Two hundred rounds or more. Clearly there was no plan, no central authority, no previously trained routine to implement.

Then an entire city was shut down, and Boston become an armed camp.  Even an idiot could see, watching cops standing shoulder to shoulder for entire blocks or hundreds of cars of every branch,  that this was gross overkill, that basically a police mob was forming.  No wonder the police tried to ban scanners as they depicted confusion and inter-turf disputes and fear.  [Compare the Boston area scanner traffic to the recordings of NYFD on 9/11. ]  This may seem unfair or shallow to note all of this, but this is all crucial to consider.  A clear review of all Boston police is required.

The objective of terrorist attack is to gain maximum leverage of the force available to the terrorist - which is always pressure cookers or small explosives and IED (9/11 was diabolical and stunning genius - the exception) - and terrify the populace so infrastructure resources are denied and that the state authorized force degenerates into a vengeful rabble. The terrorist main objective is to spark "overkill" from the state.  That state imposes ex tempo  force that is disorganized arbitrary and causes more disruption to the people than the terrorists themselves.  If the community attack allows all of that to develop, then the terrorist  achieve great victory.

By anyway you look at it,  Boston was a great victory for Tsarnaevs and for the obvious ideology they were infused with,  which is radical Salifi Islamism. 

It is a massive error to see these two as simply psychotics and one has to recognize they would do this for only the most, from their perspective, pure and correct reasons.  They are not monsters but radical ideologues.  There is no pride to be found in Boston's response and the end of hysterical fear should not be confused with achievement. Nor should  anger and disgust  in granting the Tsarnaevs'  subjectively - to them -  correct motives achieve anything - in fact it is by only recognizing the rationality of their actions can a defense then  be established.  This was a grievous blow delivered  with great success by a dedicated enemy to the USA.

The debate of whether or not Tsarnaev's were formally attached to al Qaeda is not material.  "Loners" or they are attached - and they show the brilliance and success of the online propaganda and suasion of the enemy,  how effective the enemy education and outreach programs are in realizing a terrorist event.  Only the Maoist or radical Marxist achieved such similar success, it is almost unprecedented in histotry.  And it is likely impossible that al Qaeda did not carefully consider Tsarnaev and "case" him when he was in Dagestan.   So, for  purposes of designing effective public policy and to table correct forensics of the event, Tsarnaevs should be considered mainstream members of al Qaeda - they likely are anyway.  They are now, in any case, members in absente,  with their al Qaeda  membership granted given their extreme utility to al Qaeda.  

The question to ask which answers all questions as to what were the Tsarnaev's motives and who were they working with or on behalf of is to ask, who benefits?

Therefore it  would be nonsensical to see the Tsarnaevs as anything but enemy combatants.

But it is crassly unfair and stupid to hold the usual Boston area cop accountable for this failure.  It is their leadership and structure that  is to blame.  Boston area cops showed incredible bravery and effort, especially after the MIT cop's assassination (likely the assassination was intended to generate a thoughtless police "riot" - that worked if so), and they showed total commitment. 

The entire Boston security apparatus and police obviously had little counter-terrorist capabilities or training, and the naive and panicked response gave certain victory to the Tsarnaevs.

Now, excuse the historical pun, "what is to be done"?

It is inexcusable that the demands placed upon BPD and MA State Police were  made in the first place.  It is inexcusable that the key decision made by the Governor to shut the city down  was allowed.   The starting point for the FBI self-audit is that Boston was a complete breakdown and failure with no possible explaining factors.  In short  it is vital the complete failure of the system both in prevention and response be recognized.  Intense review should be made, an audit, to identify who on the various forces  was leaking news on regular basis, correct and incorrect alike, and those identified arrested for a serious breach of national security.  They are criminals.  The legal authority and responsibility of all involved as is now must be identified and well defined - those acting without authority or incorrectly must be held to task and corrected in public forum.

A complete "redo" of how the nation addresses terrorism is required, as well as how it is prevented.

Using the in depth forensic of Boston as the start, structure and law and resources  have to be redirected, redefined or created, and reorganized on a national basis.  

The first step is to redefine posse commitatus , a set of laws birthed from Reconstruction over a 130 years ago and no longer applicable in the age of international terrorism, if an event involves terrorism (and natural catastrophe like Katrina, by the way).   Either the CIA or the FBI or a completely new authority must develop "state of the art" domestic paramilitary capabilities.  I would recommend it is a new authority housed in a permanent domestic joint operations structure, the domestic equivalent in every way to the Joint Special Operations Command shared between the CIA and the Department of Defense.  

Let us call it now the "National Counter Terrorism Authority", the NCTA.  Funding would be provided with new appropriations and current federal funding for local SWAT teams and with the FBI and ATF capabilities in this set eliminated.  Personnel can be transferred or retired rehired military personnel in the JSOC, or those in SWAT and other capabilities who can undergo and succeed in meeting the demands for the additional training required.

The NCTA would be insular and self sufficient - the entire capability able to meet two simultaneous major events in the country - and East Cost and a West Cost team, again much like the SEALS.  The entire force would be on the scene of an event within 12 hours, and the complete command and control capability on site in 3 hours.  I envision dedicated transportation and logistics of several , always on standby, C140 transports, helicopters, and semis.  Local transportation would roll out of the C140.   In 12 hours a complete and insulated mobile command and control plant would be assembled that was semi-mobile.  All communication would be encrypted and insulated.  Complete local authority would be deemed to the event commander.  Military code of justice would prevail for all results.  JAGS and judges attached are on call and authorized for all required warrants and summary judgments - the terrorists are immediately deemed enemy combatants and must appeal that status to revert to the civilian court system, but only after the event is resolved.
The NCTA would be under POTUS and receive a Congressional Charter.  A complete set of law would be written under Section 50 (the CIA section) of US Code outlining the temporary warrant of action granted to the NCTA and its supreme authority in all matters.  The NCTA would be under Congressional review in the standing committee for intelligence in both houses.

It defies reason that the structure that is thought to be required for foreign military is not duplicated as much as possible for domestic purposes.  Why the JSOC is not mirrored for domestic reasons defies reason.
The need for unique specialized skills is obvious, especially when considered in light of Boston.  Prevention must be coordinated from the national level and either replaces local forces if a local capability is not demonstrated, and certified, or coordinates with a permanent counter terrorism capability.  SWAT teams do not have the skills required.  Furthermore, it is crucial that terrorists be taken alive, even if the risk to citizens and the authorities is increased significantly.  The reasons for that are obvious as it is not the specific terrorist who has just carried out an act that is important, but the terrorists knowledge of the cell or conspiracy that may exist.  It is crucial to capture the terrorist alive to make certain there  is no conspiracy or cell.  The NCTA would understand this and have the equipment and training to lessen risk as much as possible in realizing the paramount goal of taking the terrorist alive.  It seems the Tsarnaev shoot outs with the police was the desired outcome, completing a martyrdom operation.

It is likely only NYPD may be equipped and trained to realize the above and even then it may be unjust to call on any local police authority to do all that is possible, even risking the officer's lives, to accomplish the above, especially live capture of the terrorist.  

The  obvious efforts and capability  NYPD applied or reached successfully since 9/11 has covered up a most serious flaw for the nation - that NYC may very well be the only city with a  police force with capability to handle terrorism.  The above has to be  established in one form or another shortly.  It has to be,  as the enemy took notice and it should be assumed and it should be assumed the enemy read of the Boston experience is not at all along the lines of "Boston Strong", but rather Boston was surprisingly weak, inept and vulnerable so maximum leverage of the terrorist act could be applied.

Therefore the notice provided to the enemy means a near immediate remedy must be applied to the failure that was Boston, or we should expect many such terrorists events.  The enemy's eyes have been opened, they have been educated.  We must immediately respond.

Sunday, March 31, 2013

Darfur Helped Build a Simple Effective Way to Consider 10 Year US Treasurys Real Return and Price 10 Year US Treasurys

I was impressed with the heart wrenching and yet uplifting  60 Minutes story on the 'Lost Boys" of  Darfur.  It was a followup of the 12 young men who  received asylum in the USA after fleeing Eritrea for the Sudan a decade ago.  The Darfur calamity.

http://www.cbsnews.com/video/watch/?id=50143933n

What amazes is that 12 years later after they were evacuated to the USA, despite how foreign in both terms of modernity and environment the USA was, almost all of the Darfur youth have thrived.

So I dug into population and immigration statistics to see what is going on now - first to defend an obvious view that the USA finest moments is when it becomes the 'Last Great Hope of Earth". So I wanted to show much greater immigration levels could take place that would be good for the USA economy, and also allow USA to reach even greater global altruism.

I found that despite the recent notion that the USA borders were "closed", immigration has soared in terms of the percentage makeup of the USA population growth.  I was  aware that a massive advantage the USA has over all OECD countries, and now China as well, is that we have had a population growth rate of around 1.25% over the long run, though it is declining.  With the Great Recession, the USA rate has dropped to .77% population growth, but that is still  very much higher than all of the other OECD countries, Russia, and China.




A surprise is that the population growth slowdown would be at  around   0.4%,  but for the surge in immigration that has taken place since about 2004.

In fact, immigration is now making over 1/3 of the USA population increase.


 Still it is obvious that the USA must increase immigration even more to allow the USA resume a 1.25% or better population growth rate.  That would be an approximately 2 million per annum increase  in immigration from approximately 1 million per annum now, to 3 million per annum total.

Why is population increase of importance, especially after the USA has suffered a severe solvency event and is still providing repair and with unemployment over 7%?

NGDP , or rather potential NGDP is a straight forward aggregation of the  USA native born population entering the workforce, the immigrants to the USA entering the work force, productivity and then inflation.

Immigration policy has been as effective - in forward space at least - as the Fed's QE - in providing remedy. And as native America birth death  rate decreases, immigration becomes vital so as to maintain the American current living standards.

Basically, over the last 60 years, population increase (a combination of immigration and native born) has formed  50% of real GDP,  (RGDP).

Rather than use trend GDP as per FRED etc, using RGDP composed of population increase equal weighted with productivity provides a better picture of potential.

It surprised me how robust this array was, especially when compared to realized RGDP.

Then I thought more utility from the array could be had if  the native born population increase is lagged by 18 years - a rough idea of how long after birth a contribution to the economy occurs,  and then lagging immigration increases by 7 years - keeping in mind the 60 minutes Darfur story and time it takes for an immigrant to become completely part of the US economy.  This lagged population increase with productivity resulted in a  potential GDP that was very robust when compared to other metrics, especially the risk free long rate.

Comparing this lagged population with productivity potential RGDP versus the realized RGDP shows the very large positive impact of the Reagan rationalization and reformatting of the USA economy, which I perceived to have been carried on by Clinton.  A very long and very successful growth period in the USA led to almost almost full GDP efficiency in terms of deploying all the potential. Then the Islamist war impacts, where the inefficiencies of war with a lower multiplier for public sector investment (bombs tanks and ships etc etc) along with waste, led to a falling behind  potential.  Later the solvency event clocks the USA, dropping it way beneath potential.

The usefulness of perceiving potential in this fashion versus than a CBO trend GDP, is that this potential can, or will, be closed via policy, especially when focused on immigration.  The USA has another 15% of real GDP growth to come based upon my RGDP.  And with the war inefficiencies being replaced with private sector commerce, that gain of 15% can happen rather quickly.

One can then consider the 10 year US Treasury.

It takes only common sense, and maybe a touch of Keynes, to realize that the US Treasury yield is a basket of Federal Funds rates over the tenor of that specific bond, or rather it is the expectations of those Federal Funds rates.  And the Federal Funds rate over the time of a complete business cycle, say 5 to 10 years, has to average out to NGDP.  For the last 30 years, since Volcker established the current monetary policy form of the Fed, the overshoot and undershoot has lessened.  The Great Moderation.   Another way to organize how to think on this is to consider the "Taylor Rule", not to figure out the "right" Fed Funds level, but rather to understand what are the weights of productivity and population of  a potential NGDP.

The  10 year US Treasury is showing the markets expectations for NGDP over the next 10 years, adjusted for the risk that perhaps, just perhaps, the Fed loses all reason and goes crazed, and for the positive convexity found in semi-annual coupon bond structures.  But in the  main 10 year pricing is expectations of NGDP, and the major pricing dynamics of the 10 year will be based upon the expectations changing for the general potential of NGDP.  Since I mentioned that we are considering a long enough time for at least a complete business cycle, that will mean with the modern Federal Reserve methodology,  Fed Funds will undershoot and overshoot NGDP, but will in the average, over that  tenor, be equivalent. Even if the total real return of the 10 year has to "catch up".

So, over time, the real total return of the 10 year US Treasury should approximate the all in increase in real GDP over the same time span - provided the time span is greater than a period that contains one complete business cycle.

And this is in fact what has taken place.



First, note how the adjustment by lagging the "coming on stream" of population growth makes for a more useful potential real GDP.  (Should become obvious why I am using real, as inflation has nothing to do with population or productivity.)  As said prior, one can see how the Reagan regime was a huge success.  Now for bonds, it can be seen that from early 1990s to just before the current crisis  - but for the stochastic properties in the convexity of the ten year -  the inflation impact ( or deflation), and the insurance like utility of a US Treasury longer tenor has swamped approximating RGDP.

Since I can expect maybe a slight increase in population impact to around 1%, and assuming productivity stays 1 1/4% to 1 1/2% - I can then explain some of the overshoot of US Treasurys.  But if RGDP potential stays around 2 1/2% , then over a 2 to 3 year periods a 60% hit has to be realized in 10 year US Treasurys real return.  That is back to back years of around -20% total real return.  Some of that can be inflation, of course. In short the overshoot the market priced into 10 year US Treasurys, reaching nadir in 1981, is to be repeated - and like 1981 onwards, will likely result in a 30 years of trending market - only this time a significant bear market for long maturity US Treasury.

Sunday, March 17, 2013

Cyprus: EZ's "Rogue's Island of Know Ye Men and Know Ye Measures"


In 1785 the tiny state - even then - Rhode Island was known by the rest of the 13 USA states as " Rogues' Island, the home of Know Ye men and Know Ye measures", a derisive phrase coined  for the Rhode Island's people tolerance of fast and loose speculation, pirates and smugglers.  The folks of that time most  like today's Russian oligarchs, arms smugglers, tax dodgers, money launderers, or drug lords, would flock to Rhode Island.   The "Know Ye" phrase came from the scam Rhode Islanders would play using local bank or state issued  paper money  to discharge debts in Rhode Island courts (the phrase "Know ye" was proclaimed by the judge administrating the debt dispute once the debtor presented the court with the deeply discounted paper money so to discharge a debt), effectively getting debts paid down for pennies on the dollar.  The state was infamous as a safe haven for pirates and smugglers, which in particular caused the Continental Congress great concern as tariffs were the revenue source for the new nation.   Fly by night bankers, speculators plunging into the ragged existing states debt - Massachusetts being a favorite state debt of speculators, driven to well under 20 cents on the dollar - and various other financial criminals settled in Rhode Island.   If there was a need back then to launder money - it would have been down in Rhode Island..

In short, the Rhode Island banks and financial system  was very much like today's Cyprus.

But  the ability of the 'Know ye" state to pursue financial  mischief ended in 1790 when Hamilton retired the state debt with the "Assumption of Debt", creating the US Treasury debt, eliminating speculation by providing collateral to exercise hard money seiniorage.  In the same year, the US Treasury under Hamilton also had the Continental Congress pass the "System of Cutters" Act, funding several "revenue" cutters to stop smuggling and enforce tariffs being the origins of the US Coast Guard.

These two actions - the "Assumption of Debt" and the "Revenue Cutter" Acts were the essential steps towards establishing  federalism in the USA, replacing the chaotic confederation that  enabled the criminality  in Rhode Island.

The mischief of the 'Know ye" state was one of the main motivations for the formation of the US Coast Guard and thereby start the process towards assured revenue for the federal government that allowed the conversion of state debt to the new federal debt, and define  federal prerogatives and the USA  national boundary which the 13 states lay within, rather than as a confederacy alongside.  

The Rhode Island fast furious banking ways were effectively outlawed by the creation the Hamiltonian federal monetary policy - and the newly created US Coast Guard was the implementation of eliminating the "tax avoidance" and "money laundering" of the age, by eliminating the Rhode Island smuggling and piracy.   

Rhode Island "Know ye" attributes and actions, via their elimination and remedy, were therefore  important positive  factor in the creation of a federal United States of America 

Just as Rhode Island "Know ye" contributed to the foundation and definition of the current USA federal system, Cyprus's remedy will have the same positive and beneficial impact on the Euro Zone at large, perhaps even being an important factor that in the ends with the creation of federal United States of Europe. That is if it is applied by the ECB.  

Cyprus is a near-criminal or criminal banking haven, a status that is well known to the point of a shared joke - just like the 1785 "Know ye" reputation of Rhode Island. Cyprus is the banking haven of choice for the Russian criminal oligarchy, arms traders, smugglers, and drug financiers.  Illegal activities around the world consider Cyprus first to launder funds, be they gamblers or drug lords or arms merchants.  It is  the rare locale where Middle East people  live in peace - that is if they were of  the criminal class.  

Cyprus is corrupting Europe. it is used as backdoor for the worst of the Russian criminal oligarch gain access to EU passports.

Cyprus is the EZ's  "Rogue's Island - the home of Know ye men and Know ye measures".

The need  for the current Cyprus bailout is the inevitable results of a lax confederate regulatory oversight , with a regional populace looking the other way so as to prosper, for a while at least, as a modern days "Rogue's Island".  The Cyprus stock market, such that it is, has been almost a 100% wipe out as all Cyprus listed companies become either corrupted or under the ax as the Cyprus banks their doors open like whorehouses.

The current bailout remedy proposed, will strengthen trans ECB dominion as its implementation defines ECB federal power and with ECB implementing regulatory oversight,  the EZ national borders are defined, just as the USA broders were defined by the creation of the US Coast Guard by Hamilton.   With Russian oligarchs fleeing with their deposits, a very important step in the "Monnet Process" of evolving towards  a United States of Europe occurs.  Hamilton defined the nature of the new USA federalism  with the conversion of "Rogue's Island" to a federal member state Rhode Island.    Draghi is doing the same with the conversion of Cyprus to becoming a financial federal member of the EZ.

This Cyprus event is all to the good, necessary, and will shortly be seen - if not already - as being a positive.

The Cyprus event has nothing to do with the string of crisis caused by the replacement of equalization payments required to cure intra-EZ trade imbalances with lending, as experienced in Greece and Portugal, and to some degree Italy, nor is it like the Irish and Spanish crisis caused by excess liquidity provided by the same imbalances.  The Cyprus event is singular as it is a regulatory action which in the end will be an important step in defining  a federal EZ.











Monday, March 11, 2013

A Word on Risk Free (USA)

A Word on Risk Free (USA)

 A mistake is to lump all fixed income together, perhaps separated by broad based quality identifiers - US treasuries are lumped in with investment grade US credit and sometimes with any credit that is investment grade, like emerging market debt or foreign denominated debt.  Duration is not considered with only, again, broad strokes used to differentiate cash and money markets and long term.

This common stance and approach to investing or even speculation will almost assure failure in making money or realizing objectives.

The most important factor to understand cold is that the US "full faith and credit" debt - and this even extends to receipts or contracts - is risk-free, with no gradients or waxing and waning of that quality.  US debt is also the only "risk-free" debt, with all other sovereign debt quality defined by how that country relates to the USA in a myriad of accounting identities and political relationships and specific domestic characteristics.  But I want to talk only on USA "risk-free" debt, for now.

USA "risk-free" is not based upon a collateral value or total net worth of the country or the annual flow of funds experienced.  Though all of these do contribute or allow the deciding factor that makes USA debt  "risk-free".  The underpinning of the risk-free status is solely political.  It is the the seiniorage capability of the USA and the "rule of law" allowing for long term commerce and savings without the risk of undue confiscation or expropriation - at least explicitly. The 'rule of law" is , of course. entrenched and provided by the the USA constitution - so in the end it is the nature and the dynamics of change of the US constitution which allow for the USA to achieve "risk free" status.

Now of course the ability of the USA to have designed, implemented, and maintained the USA constitution is the happy good fortune of the USA to be formed at the right time and at the right place, with additional good fortune added upon that.  The entire constitution was tested by the Civil War, and was not found wanting nor was its essence changed by the test, only elaborated with additional amendments. And then as globalization and interacting on an international basis become the means of growth, and not continental expansion, the interaction of the constitution on the international front became important as well.   Social welfare and other transfer payments and support prevent revolution or insurgency, so the constitution is not challenged by domestic status or change.  So that leaves the international constitutional interface - the challenges and enrichment  - that are now the major area that weakens or strengthens the constitution. That leaves us with the challenges to the constitution by international forces and dynamics as being the main challenge to the USA "risk free" status.

Therefore it is the international dialogue of conflict that the USA has, and has had since WW I, which define and maintain the USA "risk-free" status.

"Risk-free" status is absolute, there are no shades of gray or gradients.  No "really risk free" or "sorta risk free".  The USA is either risk free or it is not.  That is why it is specious for the credit rating agencies to even bother offering an opinion of the credit worthiness of US Treasurys.

So - for the last century - the most important factor for determining the US Treasury yield curve has - now swooping down to the base - been the ability to wage war, if need be, and to offer a defense or deterrent to those who may damage the efficacy of the US constitution.  This is what I think Lincoln was getting at when he said the USA, the Republic, the "the last great hope of Earth".

Words which are relevant for a stock broker trying to figure out an appropriate asset mix for a client's portfolio, or the most sophisticated hedge fund searching for arbitrage opportunities.

It is the constitution and resulting rule of law which allow for the seiniorage of the USA currency, which is the starting point of building the yield curve of US obligations - money being that obligation which has an instantaneous duration.

This means that politics is what defines the US Treasury 10 year rate, in the end, not demand and supply, how much debt there is how little, what China is buying or selling, or  the demographic dynamics of the USA.     So it is the consideration of politics, the leading edge being the dynamics of US foreign policy, especially conflict, that one begins and ends the consideration of the entire US Treasury yield curve.  And ground zero for that political consideration is the value of money, and the next most important rate which is the Fed Funds rate.

To say you think China holdings of US Treasurys has something to do with the pricing of US risk-free, or that the Fed has bought a trillion via QE and therefore shifting the demand supply curve - that approach shows a fundamental ignorance of the make up of the US Treasury market and how price is determined.

After one understands and accepts that the pricing of US Treasurys is political, solely, and that leads to an unqualified "risk-free" status, the US Treasury yield curve can then be priced.  That is next.

Tuesday, December 4, 2012

Divergence Between Consumer Sentiment and Corporate Sentiment

The guts of most pessimistic on the USA recovery,  and often the main focus of most in the market, is the sentiment reads of corporations.  The most well followed is the ISM manufacturing (NAPM on FRED) which yesterday dipped below 50 and into "contraction" with a read of 49.5.

The ISM Mnf, to older folks remembered and still called NAPM, is as follows:

 The Institute for Supply Management surveys more than 300 manufacturing firms on employment, production, new orders, supplier deliveries, and inventories. A composite diffusion index of national manufacturing conditions is constructed, where readings above (below) 50 percent indicate an expanding (contracting) factory sector. Export orders, import orders, backlog orders and prices paid for raw and unfinished materials are also measured, but these are not included in the overall index. 

Note this is a diffusion index  and is deliberately composed of the "establishment firms" - much as BEA payroll is polled.

In the early 80s this was somewhat a secret - few really followed it and the index was composed with input form seemingly junior line supply managers.  But as the volatility of the economy became front and center from 80s on, especially for fixed income, media and pundits picked up the importance of the index and this fed back to the participants so that a more senior weightier and thoughtful voice gave the view. and in time it became a solid reflection of the senior levels of the firm, not the old Asst VP purchasing manager.   The APM became aware of their importance and hired some economists and a party line was given rather than what a diffusion index seeks.  This still makes it very useful, though, in getting a good handle of de rigor thought from corporate America.  Which, because that is the nature of economic cycles, is reactionary and ex post and empirical, and almost never ex ante, prescient, or Bayesian type forward looking.  That consistency makes it still a must follow economic data point.  It has also been around for a long time so has a long array.  lastly, it is covering an ever shrinking, though slowly, share of GDP - now about 16% of GDP.

(Click on all images to see larger view)


Just eyeballing the above one can see all the cant and popular views of the economy to debt celinings to deficit to Europe to fiscal cliff etc etc; one can also see it is not at all in synch, but for Q2 and Q3 2009, with the SP500 improvement - in fact the correlation is negative.  Though sheer flow across the company warehouse docks insists on creep upwards, the index becomes beaten down and seemingly in two steps in March 11 and April 12.  It is not lost on me that these downward steps are usually when a organized lobbying effort or attack during the election took place.  I suspect it is organized.  The step function is not observed but for this 2 year period leading up to the election. Prior, as far as I can eyeball it moves discreetly. 


On the other side of the coin is consumer sentiment, retail, which is now 71% of GDP.  It was about 67% in 1978 when the U of Michigan started their version of consumer sentiment (UMCSENT on FRED) and has steadily creeped higher. This is a sentiment not a diffusion index so it moves as you would expect any such broadly based poll:

The University of Michigan's Consumer Survey Center questions 500 households each month on their financial conditions and attitudes about the economy. Consumer sentiment is directly related to the strength of consumer spending. Consumer confidence and consumer sentiment are two ways of talking about consumer attitudes

In contrast to the general opinion of corporate America, UMCSENT has reflected the equity market in general:


Obviously the 71% of GDP UMCSENT is at a rather extreme divergence form NAPM considering the last couple of quarters, but how much so?  First, looking at simple xy scatter doesnt seem that extraordinary at all, in fact the current pair is right smack in the middle of the available history to 1978:


Which might explain the complaceny in almost all accepting this divergence as the "norm".  But of course everyone knows scatters aint worth much unless they are of "first differences", so lets replot the xy using rolling annual % change year over year:


And then the divergence is obvious - it is historical wide and extraordinary.  I have the last xy as a red dot above and linked the previous months so the migration can be considered. That also is unique as most divergence develop from a lower value of UMCSENT and also in an clockwise arc towards the N.  They also do not last more than one month before one or the other pulls the pair into the norm.  This has been a very persistent 4 months in this extreme.  It is almost as if US corporations are motivated to be stubbornly dour as a form of communication/lobbying, or they are in a different economy, a different world.

I think it is both.  I strongly suspect there is an anti-Obama campaign, which  supported  Romney and also to offer a "deal"  to POTUS where support will be given provided the corporate tax rate in the USA is addressed and repatriation of offshore funds allowed.  The US international corporate is tied up in what has become a torquing financial structure that causes great friction to allow the USA corp to follow a swiftly expanding US recovery.  This is from the tax rate policy  they can construct offshore effective tax of 9% (AAPL) to 16%, with the mean roughly around 12%.  Therefore expansion of US capacity has to have a non-tax advantaged return  of about 3% ROI greater versus offshore projects.  This may not seem like much but it is massive when one considers cost of capital is now about 6% - a USA project has to have 16% ROI to the corporation so as to compete against the Ireland based facility generating 12%.  Then if the US corp tax  rate might be even increased - or additional health costs, the corporation is motivated to bet on Europe or China rather than USA domestic demand.  This was especially easy to present to the board when the popular press lurches from bearishly perceiving one event to another that suggests doom and gloom for the USA, especially if unemployment and other key metrics and forward views of respect are suggesting USA GDP will be capped at 2%, if not reenter contraction.  So the dual gain of impeding Obama and working to a position of leverage in terms of possibly gaining a tax deal from POTUS creates strong inertia for CAPEX and corporate investment in  the USA.  The CFO (the person now polled by NAPM) can sagely state that not only are things bad but they are getting worse, irrespective of the fact that the malls parking lots are full as he drove to work, the new cars on the road,  that houses in his town just went up 10%, and the SPX is up to 1410 from 1200 a year ago.  He can defy  his own corporate equity price gains.  But only to a point.

What we saw 4th Q 2011 might be in the making:


Where almost 4% was added in one quarter by corporate America - despite proclaiming to the world via NAPM (around 52 after being around 58 1Q 2011)  that things were still pretty miserable. That 4% represents about 175 billion.  To catch up considering the near "work to rule strike" that corporate USA has applied throughout 2012 - about 300 bil is required for catchup and then about 80 bil per quarter thereafter.  With Boeing taking down 103 bil for 2013 lease financing and autos headed to exceed 16MM sales per year - US corporates will have no choice and a panic will likely begin.  Especially as EU starts to fade and China looks like it will be a disaster.  Likely many new CEOs will appear on the scene as boards respond as this massive error in strategy is mended. You already get a sense of the scrambling and spin control as the likes of CAT and FedEx become a bit strained in blaming Europe and China and everything else under the sun, while companies which either did not make this bet or are also forward looking and honest in mending error as describing a robust US economy - UPS and Ford come to mind.   Irony is the near failure of the US auto industry in 2009, but for Ford, forced a US domestic centric policy and also with lack of much profit, if any, they were not driven by the international tax rate spread and they had no time for Sinophile spiels.

Since the divergence is unprecedented it remains to be seen how much impetus this gives private domestic investment above, or CAPEX but looking at the subsequent annual return of the SP500 to the first difference spread of the two (% ann UMCSENT-NAPM) one gets the near riskless nature of being long SP500 now - unless fo course US retail is completely bonkers and a depression is going to occur Q1 2013.  Seasonal sales blowout and the harsh but very Keynesian boost Sandy has provided already take that possibility off the table.


The above red diamond is the current spread of UMCSENT-NAPM % ann, but the forward looking SP500 return was just chosen out of thin air but the graph does suggest it is very reasonable.  What is obvious is that  the chances of losing money being long SP500, given the 15 tril behemoth with 11 tril of that in the stuff consumer confidence fuels, are very very slim indeed.

It would make sense that given the above, the realities of a a recovery for the largest economic unit in history of mankind,  recovering from a once per century downside event, and the preoccupation on parts of this economy that are near minuscule to its makeup; it would make sense to see SP500 current prospects risk adjusted as life time cheap.  Of course once that view is adopted it has implications on other assets and the correct portfolio construct.

Friday, February 10, 2012

Greece Still Can Do the Right Thing

Greece has considerable power in the form of two possible routes to take – and I suspect they are the only routes available to a patriotic Greek leadership. The current path, if supported by Greek leadership is mendaciously anti-Greek if not for all Europeans.

The two paths Greece must take, and I think will take:

1. 1 1. Mutually Assured Financial Destruction of all Europe with self imposed default – this would serve only the Greeks interest and would be predatory to all other Europeans, but is the correct route to take if the following path is not taken;

-or-

2. .........2. Absorb and agree to the essence of the troika and German party demands, but retool the method so all of Europe, including Greeks, prosper and a federal EZ results.

The first route, the MAD route, would first require the refusal to acknowledge the authority of the troika or unique EZ representatives, but insist that the only voice Greece will now discuss the issue with are the actual bond holders themselves. The Greeks would then insist that all those on record as owners of Greek debt as of February 1st 2012 will be counterparties and all bearer bond forms and other non-registered bond holders will have no voice. Then the following terms provided, dictated by Greece, noting the failure in the EU to provide transfer relief or Schengen Plan mobility as sufficient justification:

  1. Greece will leave the Euro and convert to the drachma at the rate of 1:E0.01 .
  2. Conversion will be on all assets and liabilities of Greek entities and citizens as of February 1st 2012.
  3. The Greek CB is leaving the EACB system immediately with all assets and liabilities converted to drachma as per the above.
  4. Tariffs on all Germany sourced goods may or may not be imposed upon competitiveness review.
  5. All debt of Greece if held by Greek entities or citizens on the record date will be converted to new issue at par.
  6. All Greek sovereign debt held by all those not on record or non-Greek entities or citizens will be voided under the justification of a national emergency.
  7. Greece will immediately withdraw from NATO given costs and the emergency.
  8. Greece will seek to form a common market union with Turkey and North Africa in general.
  9. Greece will seek to form a security pact with the USA.

If it were clear that the above will occur unless the second route below is followed, it would be insanity for Germany not to step away from their current position and support the dismantling of the troika plan.

The second route would be the best for all of Europe, including Greece and in the great tradition of the EU as acknowledged by Jean Monnet, would use the energy from the crisis to move Europe to a construct that would be in the best interest of all.

  1. Greece will implement the decisions of a new Euro Commission, with that agreement pre-authorized by all parts of the Greek government if not a national plebiscite.
  2. The new EC forum will composed of a national of each EZ member for a total of 17.
  3. Each EZ member will appoint this member via national popular election.
  4. Each EZ member will agree to affirm and agree to the decisions of this EC forum.
  5. Any policy or decision or remedy the EC forum decides for Greece will be applied to all EZ members in all matters from employment to tax rates and collection to fiscal policy.
  6. The EC forum will become permanent to provide compliance and to report on the general status of the EZ , Greece being one of 17 members in those reports.

It is obvious this EC forum, started to manage the Greek crisis, becomes permanent and the “upper house” or senate of the EZ and provides direct representative democracy and governance which will not only remedy the current Greek crisis, but maintain minority rights going forward and prevent such crisis in the future.

Now the equal loss of sovereignty for all EZ countries might make such a forum impossible. Then sadly Greece must follow through with the first option. Of course this would be a disaster but is the second best course of action for not only the Greeks but all of Europe. Likely such an experience will move the remaining EZ members into the second path for I see no other way to prevent contagion and the ruin of all of the EZ otherwise. In that case Greece could be forgiven and brought back into the EZ, but this will only occur if Greece presents both options now, for the record.

The worst pathway for Europe and the world is what is happening now for it is clearly a strange usurpation of power without a democratic mandate provided by various factions and blocks, one being the corporatist plutocratic block of near stateless EU bureaucracy. In fact the current path seems to only benefit this plutocracy as Germany and all are about to find out if this is the remedy. In that regard I consider the current crisis the results of what is effectively a plutocratic putsch.

Greece is at an epic and important point, yet they have considerable power they can wield on both the behalf of all Europeans and more importantly for themselves.

The machine that brought Greece here is of course the debt.

Almost all the justification of those using positions of power to impose the troika and German position is based upon qualitative and moral stances considering the notorious tax avoidance in Greece, the out of control patronage for Greek civil service jobs and the myth of indolent Greeks.

And Greeks have made this rather easy for the troika and the rest with some good street drama and chicanery which seems to confirm the veracity of the stance. The justification of the incredible austerity planned and forcing of imbalances resolution through only drastically raised unemployment so a Greek competiveness can be established in relationship to intra-EZ trade.

However these imbalances are not caused by Greek actions or mischance, but these Greek patterns would only have made the levels of debt slightly less or perhaps more easily noted and monitored – but Greece would have been in this position nonetheless.

The cause of the current Greece debt crisis is the intense intra-Europe mercantalistic trade stance of Germany (and to a lesser degree the Netherlands and Finland) which is dedicated to forcing Greece into a debtor status so as to finance German industry. Of course other countries are doing the same, but Greece being the weakest and least competitive nation from the start of the EZ was the most vulnerable.

The ineffectiveness of the Schengen Plan thesis, the extreme avoidance or refusal of transfer payments, and the lack of a competitive export industry in Greece has made the current crisis a fate. Even if Greeks had paid all taxes and swept the streets and worked as hard as Germans – they would still be at this crisis point with only a slightly stronger point of negotiation. The truth is the Greeks save more and work harder than Germans, and the tax avoidance is caused from a long history going back to the days of the Ottoman of corrupt governance that works on patronage and bribes. This culture in Greece can certainly never be remedied under duress – duress just confirms that the actions taken by the average Greek were spot on and thank God they didn’t pay those taxes as they would now face starvation – and can only be remedied under prosperity.

The above absolves Greece of any blame or need to answer and atone.

It requires that any Greek leadership, if they do not wish the leadership to go to the street and barricades, to refuse to even listen to any justification of the German party nor the troika. They must now with use of every bit of Greek power available arrive at a status that is the most beneficial to the Greek people, and after that duty is met to be mindful of the European people at large.

Tuesday, February 7, 2012

What the Greeks Can and Must Do for the Sake of Europe - First Close Down Access to Comme Chez Soi

[Comme Chez Soi is the most expensive restaurant in Brussels where I am told only the most senior Eurocrats can gain a table……]

Clausewitz stated that war was continuation of politics via another means. In an era where most feel that hard power no longer has relevancy and soft power is all, then the current play in Greece is a fascinating lab showing what happens now when war no longer is a political tool.

Germany and the troika as it approaches Greece is making a most serious error. They are not considering that that what they feel is the justification of their mandate to provide direction to Greece is based in the world of war, that economic might being the precursor to being able to prevail in war means they have the right to dictate terms to Greece.

But in fact, the relevancy of German GDP or German debt levels or German competiveness to Greece would mean all in terms of 60 German army divisions coming south, as it did in 1940 and 1941, but it is meaningless now.

In fact, though few seem to realize it, that in the “soft power” world Greece is, as far as policy design, every bit the equal to Germany. That in truth Germany has no leverage over Greece and in fact Greece as this massive borrower has huge leverage over Germany.

So Greece should realize this and come up with a game plan which empowers Greeks in this negotiation.

First, Greece has to understand a bit about what brought them here, who is providing leadership for them now, and decide where they wish to go towards. What brought Greece to this point is certain traits of cynicism and extreme local near tribal sensibilities tempted Greece to strike hard and massively at this surfeit of funding that came their way. And the funding had to come their way for Germany had to balance the accounts and fund Greece given the German predatory trade surplus. In many ways the funds that came Greece’s way are of the same “smell” as predatory lending funds for the US home markets came to broad swaths of questionable home markets in the USA. Germany could have played nice and instead of the lending could have made transfer payments to Greece, like sensible Canadians do as Ontario pays off Newfoundland for their internal trade imbalance. Germany could have said; “look, we came into the Euro with a bizarrely cheap DM conversions as we need to repair this East German mess. Let s do this for a decade and we will make transfer payments in the meantime. We will then settle out when done and help Greece with the transformation they require.” But no, like Greentree or Countrywide, Germans (and also to an important degree those sneaky fellow travelers like Finland (cell phones), Netherlands (high end goods) and others snuck into the deal) trumpeted virtue and attempted to dump on Greeks, counting on the obvious silliness and corruption of the Greeks to mask the true source of the debt load.

Now the Greek leadership, ever since that first dinner at Comme Chez Soi that they attended on the invite at their fellow Harvard or MIT or Georgetown alum (though French and oh so polished or tres chic) and which made their head spin, are like guys from Iowa who made it big in NYC – they will do anything to not go back and serve in Athens. They love Brussels. They love the French. Finally they are recognized for the true intellectual giants that they are despite their bushy mustaches. Finally they are Europeans! No, they are Supra-Europeans! They are “New Men” of the third way, a way beyond ugly back rooms in Athens and that rather embarrassing stint washing dishes for the Porcelain Club dinners in Cambridge, MA. They had finally transcended Greekhood! And they will sell all the islands of the Aegean and betray any Greeks and even sell Greece itself to maintain these new sparkling privileges. They are never going back. They are betraying Greece and in the most insidious way possible by first fooling and betraying themselves. All for the pressed duck at Chez Soi.

Greeks should immediately see that unless they too can get a seat at Chez Soi (they cannot), they better dump all the current leadership. A pretty good way is to declare that due to the emergency - and of course there will be errors for many, but this is an emergency – anyone educated in the great graduate schools of the USA and also served in any function for the EU machinery in Brussels will be locked up for the next few months. Sorry – but the spirit of Demosthenes calls for their sacrifice.

Now what to do, and what are the Greek strengths in the bargaining.

The Greeks should ask themselves if they still wish for a federal Eurozone which they will be a member of and share in a common currency. And if so what form should that EZ take. Obviously the current form sucks and requires great changes. Greece should understand, that as likely the weaker sister in the EZ for decades to come, the EZ should be in a form that empowers minority rights. It is not hard to define the optimal form – just take advantage of the USA education with a million causalities from the Civil War and what has transpired there since– for the USA Civil War was all about, because of their embrace of the odious system of slavery, weaker member states who had to face more populous and economically powerful states and still divide the pie with any equality. Greece has a huge leg up here as they don’t have to do a back flip to dump anything like slavery – maybe do a bit of work on local level political corruption and brush up on civitas, but that’s it. Greece then obviously has only one path or form which would make the EZ bearable and workable for Greeks (and really all PIIGS) and that is to have one of the governing bodies of the EZ which would have full equivalency of power to any other EZ governance bodies but be an upper chamber with the same number of deputies or senators or whatever they are called per each EZ member state. And that to maintain that equivalency requires a supreme judiciary to define and maintain that equivalency between units, and to judge things, this judiciary needs a constitution to work over. So Greeks should determine that the only acceptable form the EZ can take is where one of the governance bodies has to be an upper house with equal representation per state, no matter how small or large that state is and that no other arm of the government can have more power.

So once the objective is realized, the Greeks have to table this as a nonnegotiable requirement for any discussion.

Second, the Greeks must insist on the sanctity and priority of Europe upon itself. There is absolutely no roll for any suprasovereign institution like the IMF. For if the IMF is involved , some will not like the outcome and the presence of the IMF forever weakens the binding of the agreement outcome and justifies insurgency.

Next, the Greeks require as nonnegotiable that all EZ members form the body that negotiates the settlement, replacing the troika, and that all representatives of this body be made up of one per member country, and that this member be authorized to negotiate based upon a legislative ruling. And that this member in the forum not be the executive of the country. No Merkel, no Papademos. Of course this forum becomes the seed for the “upper house” senate and begins to set precedent for federal empowerment.

Then, the Greeks should insist as nonnegotiable that any solution or remedy be bonded for performance equally by all members of the EZ and that any application of the remedy in terms of reorganizing Greece procedures or governance become adopted in exactly the same manner by all members. Then Greece would then comply with the outcome.

Crisis solved and the basis for a federal EZ laid in the doing.

But all the above is required on a nonnegotiable basis – what leverage or bargaining strength does Greece have to gain this forum?

The most important factor is Clausewitz is off the table. There are no 60 divisions of German soldiers headed towards Greece (this time) and Greece can thereby make certain the above forum occurs. Greeks can do this by making the alternative so loathsome, so unpleasant for the rest of the EZ that there is compliance. Since there is no possibility of a war of enforcement or a punitive adventure, it is not difficult for Greece to design such actions. But it is crucial that the current leadership not be the ones to level the threat nor the design – for Chez Soi calls always. Also the choice cannot be a threat but communicated with firmness and great clarity and assured implementation if the above forum is not provided. This must be the financial and economic equivalent of a thermo nuke for this is in essence a policy of assured mutual destruction – MAD.

The MAD weapon:

Irrevocably and completely at Noon February 9th, 2012 Greece will enact the following:

  • All Greek debt held by institutions without at least 30% Greek ownership will be repudiated;
  • All Greek debt held by the ECB or any non-Greek EACB will be repudiated;
  • All property domiciled in Greece that is not held by at least 60% Greek ownership will be registered as “foreign held”;
  • All such foreign held property will have a surcharge tax of 10% of asset value levied as of January 1st 2012 which if not paid in 5 business days will be forfeitured to the Greek state;
  • All such foreign held property will be levied an annual tax of 8%;
  • All Euro denominated assets, whether cash or financial or property, will be exchanged for drachma at the rate of 1: E0.0050;
  • All Euro denominated debt, no matter where the domicile owed by Greek institutions or citizens will be converted to drachma at the rate of 1:E0.0050;
  • Greece will immediately withdraw from NATO;
  • No right of passage will be provided to any non-Greek military vehicles;
  • Greece will immediately require visas for all other EU member citizens;
  • Greece will provide a 0% corporate tax rate for all new ventures for 10 years;
  • Greece will lower the corporate tax rate to 10%;
  • Greece will lower the capital gains tax rate to 10%;
  • Greece will abolish estate tax;
  • Greece will impose a 25% flat tax on all income with no deductions for 10 years.
  • Greece can only rescind the above and revert to the Euro and the EZ provided a E250 billion subsidization fund is made available and the above repudiation remains.

As soon as Germany realize that the above will happen without the federal forum and elimination of the troika and the subsuming of Germany current approach to only one voice among 17, Germany will comply and then do as they always should have done and seek consensus via the democracy that Greece first presented to the world in the days of the Demos.

I will even go further. The above isn't far fetched and I strongly feel that ether in a hodge podge and chaotic fashion or with leadership and vision the above will occur. It is far better for the EZ if the forum approach becomes the pathway applied now. These swaps between ECB and EFSF and so on and so forth are canards, ruses.

What is striking is that the Chez Soi sell out is not Greek specific but is actually infecting all of the EZ. In fact it can be perceived that under the smoke and sparks of the specifics of the Greece situation, a general supra-sovereign putsch is underway and that Merkel , assuming she is dedicated to the German constitution, is a dupe of this Chez Soi cabal. That “something happened” over the last decade where the likes of Jean Monnet and Adenauer were replaced by a subtle but very powerful stateless plutocracy. Chez Soi diners all. What I proposed and the logic I table was actually the expected development and outcome for the formation of the United States of Europe. That only a crisis like that occurring now would wake folks up and get them past their deadly and inefficient and destructive tribalism of area nationalism. I think the crisis has achieved that objective, but what Jean Monnet did not plan for or expect is this vast organized international cabal of stateless, proudly so by the way, plutocrats who wish to simply abolish sovereignty and federalism entire and impose a plutocracy. That the descendants of Marxism and other corporatists would use the opaque confusion and complexity of deconstrustionalism of the French with the neo-Adorno Habermasian ‘deliberative democracy” and basically carry off a putsch. With Clausewitz out of the room very strange mutations have occurred indeed.